Dr. John Gottman's groundbreaking research identified four communication patterns he termed "The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse." I've witnessed firsthand the destructive power these behaviors can wield. Criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling are not just relationship killers; they're power plays disguised as communication. It's time to reclaim your power and dominate your interactions. The Axioms of Love provide a framework for establishing boundaries and expectations, but it's up to you to enforce them.
Let's explore how to harness your inner power and conquer these destructive forces.
Understanding the Four Horsemen
Criticism: Unlike constructive feedback, criticism attacks a person's character rather than their behavior. In polyamory, this can manifest as blaming a partner for another relationship's issues or making sweeping generalizations about their character.
Contempt: This is the most corrosive of the Four Horsemen, expressing disdain or superiority. In polyamorous relationships, contempt can arise from feeling undervalued, disrespected, or compared unfavorably to other partners.
Defensiveness: When faced with criticism, defensiveness is a common response. In polyamory, it can escalate conflict by preventing open communication and problem-solving.
Stonewalling: This is the withdrawal from a conversation, often expressed through silence, changing the subject, or physically leaving. In polyamory, stonewalling can create feelings of isolation and neglect.
Polyamorous relationships often involve complex dynamics with multiple partners. The Four Horsemen can exacerbate these complexities, leading to jealousy, resentment, and feelings of insecurity. It's crucial to recognize these patterns and address them proactively to maintain healthy and fulfilling relationships. Let's take a look at each of these horsemen in detail.
Criticism: The First Horseman
Dr. John Gottman identified criticism as the first of his infamous "Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse" in relationships. While this concept originated in the context of monogamy, it's equally relevant to polyamorous dynamics. Criticism, when unchecked, can erode trust, intimacy, and overall relationship satisfaction.
What is Criticism?
Unlike a complaint, which focuses on a specific behavior or event, criticism is a global attack on a person’s character. It often starts with "you" statements and places blame rather than addressing a specific issue. In polyamory, this can be particularly damaging as it can create a ripple effect of insecurity and resentment among all partners involved.
Criticism in Polyamory
In polyamorous relationships, the potential for criticism is magnified due to the intricate dynamics between multiple partners. Common forms of criticism in this context include:
Comparing partners: This can be devastating, leading to feelings of inadequacy and competition. Statements like, “You’re never as attentive as [other partner’s name]” are harmful.
Criticizing relationship structure: This can undermine a partner's sense of security and trust. Comments like, “I don’t like how much time you spend with [other partner’s name]” can create tension.
Blaming a partner for another relationship's issues: This can lead to feelings of guilt and resentment. Statements such as, “Your relationship with [other partner’s name] is causing problems in our relationship” oversimplify complex issues.
The Impact of Criticism
Criticism can have far-reaching consequences in polyamorous relationships:
Erosion of trust: Consistent criticism can damage the foundation of trust between partners.
Increased conflict: Criticism often leads to defensive responses, escalating conflict rather than resolving it.
Damage to self-esteem: Constant criticism can undermine a partner’s sense of self-worth.
Strain on the entire relationship system: Criticism between two partners can affect the dynamics between all involved.
Building a Culture of Constructive Feedback
To counteract the destructive effects of criticism, polyamorous partners should strive to create a culture of open, honest, and respectful communication. This involves:
Using "I" statements: Expressing feelings and needs without blaming the other person.
Focusing on specific behaviors: Clearly articulating what bothers you without attacking the person.
Active listening: Understanding your partner's perspective before responding.
Seeking compromise: Finding solutions that work for everyone involved.
By understanding the destructive nature of criticism and implementing strategies for constructive communication, polyamorous individuals can build stronger, more resilient relationships.
Contempt: The Corrosive Horseman in Polyamory
Dr. John Gottman identified contempt as the most destructive of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse in relationships. It's a potent form of disrespect that can quickly erode trust and intimacy. While this concept is often discussed in monogamous relationships, it is equally harmful in polyamorous dynamics.
What is Contempt?
Contempt is more than just criticism; it's a deep-seated feeling of superiority over one's partner. It's expressed through sarcasm, mockery, eye-rolling, name-calling, and hostile humor. Unlike criticism, which attacks behavior, contempt attacks a person's character.
Contempt in Polyamory
In polyamorous relationships, contempt can take on even more complex forms. It can manifest as:
Comparing partners negatively: Treating one partner with contempt while idealizing another.
Devaluing a partner's needs or feelings: Dismissing a partner's concerns as unimportant or unreasonable.
Treating a partner like an inferior: Acting as if one partner is less worthy or deserving of respect.
Shaming a partner for their relationship choices: Making derogatory comments about a partner's other relationships.
The Impact of Contempt
Contempt is a relationship killer. Its effects in polyamorous relationships can be devastating:
Destruction of trust: Contempt shatters the foundation of trust between partners.
Increased conflict: It fuels resentment and defensiveness, leading to more frequent and intense arguments.
Damage to self-esteem: Being on the receiving end of contempt can erode a person's sense of self-worth.
Strain on the entire relationship system: Contempt between two partners can negatively impact all relationships within the polyamorous network.
Building Respect and Appreciation
To counter the destructive force of contempt, polyamorous partners must cultivate a culture of respect and appreciation. This involves:
Active listening: Giving full attention to a partner without interrupting or judging.
Empathy: Trying to understand a partner's perspective, even if you disagree.
Kindness: Speaking and acting with compassion and consideration.
Appreciation: Expressing gratitude for a partner's contributions to the relationship.
Remember, contempt is a choice. By being mindful of our communication and cultivating a positive atmosphere, polyamorous individuals can build strong, resilient, and loving relationships.
Defensiveness: Building Walls in Polyamory
The third horseman in Dr. John Gottman's quartet of relationship destroyers is defensiveness. It's a natural human response to feeling attacked, but when it becomes a habitual pattern, it can severely damage a relationship. This is particularly true in the complex dynamics of polyamory.
What is Defensiveness?
Defensiveness is a protective mechanism that arises when we feel blamed or criticized. It often involves making excuses, denying responsibility, or counterattacking. While it's a normal human reaction, it can escalate conflict and prevent effective communication.
Defensiveness in Polyamory
In polyamorous relationships, defensiveness can take many forms:
Blaming other partners: Shifting responsibility for relationship issues onto other partners.
Justifying one's actions: Providing elaborate explanations to defend one's behavior.
Counterattacking: Responding to criticism with criticism.
Withdrawing: Avoiding the conversation altogether.
Defensiveness can create a climate of blame and resentment, making it difficult to address underlying issues. It can also erode trust and intimacy between partners.
The Impact of Defensiveness
Defensiveness can have serious consequences for polyamorous relationships:
Stalled communication: Defensiveness hinders open and honest dialogue.
Escalating conflict: It can turn disagreements into full-blown arguments.
Damage to trust: Consistent defensiveness can erode trust between partners.
Increased feelings of insecurity: Defensive behavior can make partners feel undervalued or unloved.
Taking Responsibility and Building Trust
To overcome defensiveness, polyamorous partners need to cultivate a culture of responsibility and accountability. This involves:
Active listening: Focusing on understanding your partner's perspective.
Taking responsibility: Owning your part in the problem.
Using "I" statements: Expressing your feelings without blaming the other person.
Seeking compromise: Finding solutions that work for everyone involved.
Being vulnerable is not a sign of weakness but a strength. By taking responsibility for your actions and being open to feedback, you can build stronger, more resilient polyamorous relationships.
Stonewalling: The Silent Treatment in Polyamory
The final horseman in Dr. John Gottman's quartet of relationship destroyers is stonewalling. This involves withdrawing from a conversation, either physically or emotionally. It's a silent but potent form of communication avoidance that can have devastating consequences for any relationship, including polyamorous ones.
What is Stonewalling?
Stonewalling is more than just silence; it's a deliberate attempt to shut down communication. It can manifest as avoiding eye contact, changing the subject, or physically removing oneself from the situation. This behavior often occurs when a person feels overwhelmed or flooded with emotion.
Stonewalling in Polyamory
In polyamorous relationships, stonewalling can take on added complexity. It can appear as:
Withdrawing from a partner or the entire relationship dynamic: Creating emotional distance to avoid conflict.
Ignoring a partner's feelings or concerns: Pretending not to hear or understand.
Disengaging from group discussions: Avoiding conversations involving multiple partners.
Creating physical distance: Spending more time alone or with other partners.
Stonewalling can lead to feelings of isolation, rejection, and resentment among all partners involved.
The Impact of Stonewalling
The consequences of stonewalling in polyamory can be far-reaching:
Unresolved conflicts: Issues remain unaddressed and fester over time.
Erosion of trust: Partners may feel like their concerns are unimportant.
Increased feelings of insecurity: Stonewalling can make partners doubt their value in the relationship.
Damage to the overall relationship dynamic: It can create a climate of tension and avoidance.
Building Open and Honest Communication
Overcoming stonewalling requires a commitment to open and honest communication. This involves:
Identifying triggers: Understanding what situations lead to stonewalling.
Taking breaks: If feeling overwhelmed, taking a short break to calm down can be helpful.
Using "I" statements: Expressing feelings without blaming the other person.
Seeking professional help: If stonewalling is a persistent problem, couples therapy can be beneficial.
Open communication is the foundation of any healthy relationship, including polyamorous ones. By addressing stonewalling and fostering a climate of emotional safety, partners can build stronger, more resilient connections.
Polyamory, a relationship style built on honesty and openness, requires a strong foundation of communication. Dr. John Gottman’s Four Horsemen—criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling—can erode this foundation. These toxic behaviors, when unchecked, can create a climate of fear, resentment, and distrust within a polyamorous relationship. By understanding these destructive patterns and applying the principles of The Axioms of Love, polyamorous individuals can cultivate healthier, more fulfilling connections.
Remember, every relationship, whether monogamous or polyamorous, experiences challenges. The journey towards healthier communication is ongoing. By actively working to eliminate the Four Horsemen and fostering an environment of respect, empathy, and open dialogue, polyamorous partners can build strong, lasting bonds. The Axioms of Love provide a roadmap for navigating the complexities of polyamory with love, understanding, and compassion.
Comments